Compatible/Incompatible Hard Drives(3.5: Difference between revisions

From QNAPedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older edit
Tnt (talk | contribs)
1 edit
Tag: visualeditor-switched
SpyderX (talk | contribs)
3 edits
Tag: visualeditor-switched
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 416: Line 416:
! width="120" | Model Number
! width="120" | Model Number
! width="80" | HD FW
! width="80" | HD FW
! width="80" | Capacity (GB)
! width="80" | Capacity<br>( '''''TB''''' )
! width="80" | RAID
! width="80" | RAID
! width="100" | NAS Model
! width="100" | NAS Model
Line 422: Line 422:
! width="100" | Reporter
! width="100" | Reporter
! width="80" | YYYY.MM
! width="80" | YYYY.MM
! width="280" | Remark<br/>
! width="280" | Remarks
|-
|-
| WD Caviar SE WD3200AAJS
| <br/>
| 320 GB
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| Spindown: Yes, Copy of original [[User_Reported_Compatible_Hard_Drives|User Reported Compatible Hard Drives]] page
|-
| WDC WD5003ABYX-01WER01.0
| 04.05G05
| 500 GB
| 4
| TS-439proII+
| 3.3.2 Build 0819T
| RoSa
| 2010.12
|  
|  
<br/>WDC WD10EARS-00Y5B1
4 drives Setup in RAID 5. Drives have 64MB Cache and<br/>labled Enterprise Storage. Works perfectly with ESXi3.5<br/>and iSCSI Targets.
 
No read/write errors or performance issues.<br/>Disks are not encrypted (makes hardly sense for a raid array)
|-


| WDC WD5000AAKS-07YGA0
| 12.01C02
| 500 GB
| 1
| TS-459 Pro+
| 3.5.1 build 1002T
| mikahe
| 2011.10
| SATA II RAID 1 with Samsung HD501LJ
|-
| WD Caviar Green WD6400AADS-00M2B01.0
| 01.00A01
| 640 GB
| Single
| TS-119
| 3.3.6 Build 1109
| hardstyler
| 2010.11
| No issues, very quiet.
|-
| WD10EAVS-00D7B1
| 01.0
| 1 TB
| <br/>
| TS-209p
| 3.3.0
| Merry
| 11-2010
| Works intern. Attaching it by USB does not work!
|-
| WDC WD10EARS-00Y5B1
| 80.0
| 80.0
| 1 TB
| 1 TB
Line 434: Line 491:
| Ali Saleh
| Ali Saleh
| 2011.05
| 2011.05
|  
| Had These Drives In Raid 1 with NAS Running Over 1 Year Now - No Problem - Quiet - Fast - Perfect
Had These Drives In Raid 1 with NAS Running Over 1 Year Now - No Problem - Quiet - Fast - Perfect
 
|-
|-
| WDC WD15EADS-00P8B0
| 01.00A01
| 1.5TB
| 0
| TS-439 Pro
| 3.1.1 0815T,<br/>3.1.2 1014,<br/>3.2.0 1107 Beta
| Kanchelsis
| 2009.11
|
Several users report reliability and performance issues during I/O operations like (1) high LCC counts and (2) freezes and hiccups. WDIDLE3 <u>may</u> solve (1).&nbsp; (2) remains unsolved.
'''edit: these desktop drives are not supported for RAID use by Western Digital'''


|-
| WDC WD10EACS-22D6B0
| WDC WD10EACS-22D6B0
| 01.01A01
| 01.01A01
| 1TB
| 1 TB
| 1
| 1
| TS-253 Pro
| TS-253 Pro
| 4.2.0
| 4.2.0
| RaceDuck
| RaceDuck
| 2015.11<br/>
| 2015.11
|
| <br/>
|-
|-
| WDC WD1002FBYS-02A6B0
| WDC WD1002FBYS-02A6B0
| 03.00C06
| 03.00C06
| 1TB
| 1 TB
| 5
| 5
| TS-509 Pro
| TS-509 Pro
Line 472: Line 515:
| These RE3 drives are very reliable harddives, designed for RAID config. did not had any issues with 3 of them using them in raid 5 config.
| These RE3 drives are very reliable harddives, designed for RAID config. did not had any issues with 3 of them using them in raid 5 config.
|-
|-
| WD Caviar Green WD10EADS
| <br/>
| 1 TB
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| Spindown: Yes, Copy of original [[User_Reported_Compatible_Hard_Drives|User Reported Compatible Hard Drives]] page
|-
| WDC WD10EZEX
| 08RKKA080.0
| 1 TB
| Single
| TS-112
| 3.8.1
| csumy
| 2012.12
| No problem, works great with high speed.
|-
| WDC WD10EZRX
| &nbsp;
| 1 TB
| 5
| TS-420
| 4.0.5
| Stefan
| 2013.12
| No problem, RAID5 with 4 equal disks.<br/>
|-
| WDC WD15EADS-00P8B0
| 01.00A01
| 1.5TB
| 0
| TS-439 Pro
| 3.1.1 0815T,<br/>3.1.2 1014,<br/>3.2.0 1107 Beta
| Kanchelsis
| 2009.11
|
Several users report reliability and performance issues during I/O operations like (1) high LCC counts and (2) freezes and hiccups. WDIDLE3 <u>may</u> solve (1).&nbsp; (2) remains unsolved.
'''edit: these desktop drives are not supported for RAID use by Western Digital'''
|-
| WDC WD2002FYPS-01U1B0
| WDC WD2002FYPS-01U1B0
| 04.05G05
| 04.05G05
| 2TB
| 2 TB
| 1
| 1
| TS-509 pro
| TS-509 pro
| 3.2.0 1212T<br/>
| 3.2.0 1212T
| Yeroon
| Yeroon
| 2009.11
| 2009.11
Line 484: Line 575:


download bootable CD with right FW and WDIDLE tool here: [http://wdcutil.homeip.net http://wdcutil.homeip.net]
download bootable CD with right FW and WDIDLE tool here: [http://wdcutil.homeip.net http://wdcutil.homeip.net]
|-


|-
| WDC WD2002FYPS-01U1B1
| WDC WD2002FYPS-01U1B1
| 04.05G05
| 04.05G05
| 2TB
| 2 TB
| 6
| 6
| TS-809RP
| TS-809RP
Line 494: Line 585:
| ftan
| ftan
| 2010.3
| 2010.3
|  
| 8 drives came directly from WD with the latest firmware. Setup in RAID 6. So far 1270 Hours ~ 9500 LCC. Did not WDIDLE.
8 drives came directly from WD with the latest firmware. Setup in RAID 6. So far 1270 Hours ~ 9500 LCC. Did not WDIDLE.


Raid and drive stable since build, no read/write errors or performance issues.
Raid and drive stable since build, no read/write errors or performance issues.
|-


|-
| WDC WD20EARS-00S8B1 80.0
| WDC WD20EARS-00S8B1 80.0
| 80.00A80
| 80.00A80
| 2TB (decimal)<br/>1863GB (binary)
| 2 TB (decimal)<br/>1863GB (binary)
| JBOD
| JBOD
| TS-210
| TS-210
Line 510: Line 598:
| doofas
| doofas
| 2010.06
| 2010.06
|  
| Single "Green" SATA ATA-8 drive; very quiet.<br/>No issues seen during installation and approximately 2 months of NAS uptime
Single "Green" SATA ATA-8 drive; very quiet.<br/>No issues seen during installation and approximately 2 months of NAS uptime
 
|-
|-
| WD Caviar SE WD3200AAJS
| <br/>
| 320
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
|
Spindown: Yes, Copy of original [[User_Reported_Compatible_Hard_Drives|User Reported Compatible Hard Drives]] page


| WDC WD20EARX-00PASB0531.0
| 51.0AB51
| 2 TB
| Single
| TS-412
| 3.8.2
| Wond1979
| 2013.03
| No problem, works great in single mode quiet and slow temp.
|-
|-
| WD Caviar Green WD10EADS
| <br/>
| 1TB
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
|
Spindown: Yes, Copy of original [[User_Reported_Compatible_Hard_Drives|User Reported Compatible Hard Drives]] page


|-
| WD Caviar Green WD20EADS-00R6B0
| WD Caviar Green WD20EADS-00R6B0
| <br/>
| <br/>
| 2TB
| 2 TB
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
Line 550: Line 624:
| WD Caviar Green WD20EARS-00J2GB080.0
| WD Caviar Green WD20EARS-00J2GB080.0
| <br/>
| <br/>
| 2TB
| 2 TB
| RAID5
| RAID5
| TS-439 Pro II
| TS-439 Pro II
Line 558: Line 632:
| No issues; very quiet.
| No issues; very quiet.
|-
|-
|
WD Caviar Green


WD6400AADS-
| WDC WD20EARS
 
| 07MVWB051.0
00M2B01.0
| 2 TB
 
| 10
| 01.00A01
| TS-419P
| 640
| 3.6.1 Build 0302T
| Single
| Kim Haverblad
| TS-119
| 2012.06
| 3.3.6 Build 1109
| Two Disks running with RAID 10 together with two Seagate drives. Been running for well over a year without any issues.<br/>
| hardstyler
| 2010.11
| No issues, very quiet.
|-
| WD10EAVS-00D7B1
| 01.0
| 1TB
| <br/>
| TS-209p
| 3.3.0
| Merry
| 11-2010
| Works intern. Attaching it by USB does not work!
|-
|-
| WDC WD5003ABYX-01WER01.0
| 04.05G05
| 500GB
| 4
| TS-439proII+
| 3.3.2 Build 0819T
| RoSa
| 2010.12
|
4 drives Setup in RAID 5. Drives have 64MB Cache and<br/>labled Enterprise Storage. Works perfectly with ESXi3.5<br/>and iSCSI Targets.
No read/write errors or performance issues.<br/>Disks are not encrypted (makes hardly sense for a raid array)


|-
| WD Caviar 3 TB<br/>(WD30EZRX)
| WD Caviar 3 TB<br/>( WD30EZRX)<br/>
| <br/>
| <br/>
| 3TB<br/>
| 3 TB
| <br/>
| <br/>
| TS-119<br/>
| TS-119
| 3.4.4<br/>Build0718<br/>
| 3.4.4<br/>Build0718
| maierhe<br/>
| maierhe
| 2011.07<br/>
| 2011.07
| NAS works well with WD WD30EZRS and very quiet. HDD temperature with constant access to approximately 40°C/104°F. According to WD permitted to 60 ° C/140F.<br/>
| NAS works well with WD WD30EZRS and very quiet. HDD temperature with constant access to approximately 40°C/104°F. According to WD permitted to 60 ° C/140F.
|-
|-
| WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX
| WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX
| <br/>
| <br/>
Line 618: Line 665:
| Two disks prepared with wdidle3 /d, configured into a RAID-0. Performing fine.
| Two disks prepared with wdidle3 /d, configured into a RAID-0. Performing fine.
|-
|-
| WDC WD5000AAKS-07YGA0<br/>
 
| 12.01C02<br/>
| 500<br/>
| 1<br/>
| TS-459 Pro+<br/>
| 3.5.1 build 1002T<br/>
| mikahe<br/>
| 2011.10<br/>
| SATA II RAID 1 with Samsung HD501LJ<br/>
|-
| WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX
| WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX
| 00MMMB080.0<br/>
| 00MMMB080.0
| 3 TB&nbsp;
| 3 TB
| 0 Stripped
| 0<br/>Stripped
| T-210
| T-210
| 3.5.1 B1002
| 3.5.1 B1002
Line 638: Line 676:
| Two Disks, but there was problems with the Firmware because i got the T-210 with 3.1.8 and this FW does not support 3TB, so i did it with a 1TB HDD and upgrade to 3.5.1 and exchange to 2x 3TB works fine ..!!
| Two Disks, but there was problems with the Firmware because i got the T-210 with 3.1.8 and this FW does not support 3TB, so i did it with a 1TB HDD and upgrade to 3.5.1 and exchange to 2x 3TB works fine ..!!
|-
|-
|
WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX


| 80.00A80<br/>
| WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX
| 3TB<br/>
| 80.00A80
| 5<br/>
| 3 TB
| TS-439 Pro<br/>
| 5
| 3.5.2 build 1126T<br/>
| TS-439 Pro
| Davide.f75<br/>
| 3.5.2 build 1126T
| 2012.01<br/>
| Davide.f75
| it is recommended to disable applications in the NAS during RAID volume expansion, and this for any hard drive, regardless of compatibility with the NAS&nbsp;!!<br/>
| 2012.01
| it is recommended to disable applications in the NAS during RAID volume expansion, and this for any hard drive, regardless of compatibility with the NAS&nbsp;!!
|-
|-
| WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX<br/>
| 80.00A80<br/>
| 3TB<br/>
| 5<br/>
| TS-559 Pro+<br/>
| 3.7.3 build 20120801<br/>
| buggy82<br/>
| 2013.01<br/>
| Very quiet, very fast and not a single problem yet. 3+ months running in a RAID-5 Array of five disks.<br/>
|-
|
WDC WD20EARS


| 07MVWB051.0<br/>
| WD Caviar Green<br>WD30EZRX
| 2 TB<br/>
| 80.00A80
| 10<br/>
| 3 TB
| TS-419P<br/>
| 5
| 3.6.1 Build 0302T<br/>
| TS-559 Pro+
| Kim Haverblad<br/>
| 3.7.3 build 20120801
| 2012.06<br/>
| buggy82
| Two Disks running with RAID 10 together with two Seagate drives. Been running for well over a year without any issues.<br/>
| 2013.01
| Very quiet, very fast and not a single problem yet. 3+ months running in a RAID-5 Array of five disks.
|-
|-
|
WDC WD30EFRX


| 80.00A8<br/>
| WDC WD30EFRX
| 3 TB<br/>
| 80.00A8
| 4<br/>
| 3 TB
| TS-469L<br/>
| 4
| 3.8.1<br/>
| TS-469L
| Rafale<br/>
| 3.8.1
| 2012.12<br/>
| Rafale
| 4x Caviar RED in RAID5. works great.<br/>
| 2012.12
| 4x Caviar RED in RAID5. works great.
|-
|-
|
WDC WD10EZEX&nbsp;


| 08RKKA080.0<br/>&nbsp;
| WDC WD80EFBX
| 1 TB<br/>&nbsp;
| 85.00A85
| Single<br/>&nbsp;
| 8 TB
| TS-112<br/>&nbsp;
| 6
| 3.8.1<br/>&nbsp;
| TS-469L
| csumy<br/>&nbsp;
| 4.3.4
| 2012.12<br/>&nbsp;
| Spyder
| No problem, works great with high speed.<br/>
| 2022.05
| 4x WD Red Plus 8TB, 16~24 hours per drive rebuild, ~12 hours pool expansion, no issues.<br/>The 2-6 TB models are verified, so suspected newer 8 TB also will work, comments on expansion max to 16TB made me choose 8TB vs larger in case could not expand, vs full rebuild.
|-
|-
|
WDC WD20EARX-00PASB0531.0


| 51.0AB51<br/>&nbsp;
| 2 TB<br/>&nbsp;
| Single<br/>&nbsp;
| TS-412<br/>&nbsp;
| 3.8.2<br/>&nbsp;
| Wond1979<br/>&nbsp;
| 2013.03<br/>&nbsp;
| No problem, works great in single mode quiet and slow temp.<br/>
|-
|
WDC WD10EZRX
| <br/>&nbsp;
| 1 TB<br/>&nbsp;
| 5<br/>&nbsp;
| TS-420<br/>&nbsp;
| 4.0.5<br/>&nbsp;
| Stefan<br/>&nbsp;
| 2013.12<br/>&nbsp;
| No problem, RAID5 with 4 equal disks.<br/>
|}
|}


Latest revision as of 18:52, 9 May 2022

Compatible Hard Drives(3.5")

Notice: QNAP cannot guarantee the drives on the list below are really compatible. Please refer to the official hard drive compatibility list as all the hard drive has been tested under certain test conditions. (http://www.qnap.com/useng/?sn=4085&lang=en-us)


Source(s): Compatible Hard Drives

Hitachi

Model Number HD FW Capacity
(GB) 		Raid NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark
HD31000 IDK/7K
 		JP4OA39C
 		1000
 		1
 TS-419P

3.23
0212

cbragwel 2010.02

Running 2 of these in RAID 1 with no issues

HDP725050GLA360 GM4O
  GM4OA5CA
 500
 0
 TS-219P
 3.4.1 Build 0315T
 diphe
 2010.03
 Running 2 of these in RAID 0 for 2 years with no issues
HDS722020ALA330 JKOA28A
 		2000
 		1
 TS-259 3.2.7
0526T 		Gershwin 2010.06 2 HDD's fully compatible in RAID 1
HDS721010CLA332
 JP4OA3EA 1000 Single TS-209

3.3.0
0924T

eilctw 2010.11 Drive 1: Seagate ST 31000333AS SD1B 1000GB
HDS5C1010CLA382 JC4OA3HB 1000 5 TS-409 Pro 3.1.0 Build 0708T Scromple 2010.12 Array originally made with Seagate 750GB drives. Disk 2 failed. Used this Hitachi model to replace failed drive in the array.
HDS5C3020ALA632 ML6OA580 2000 5 TS-419P+

3.4.2 Build 0331T

Jesbo 2011.05 New server with 4 drives. Drives tested JBOD and RAID-5 with 24 hour continuous read/write. QNAP tests run fine. Drives spin up/down when hibernating. So far no issues.
HDS5C3020ALA632 ML6OA580 2000 6 TS-659 Pro II 3.4.2 0331T and 3.4.3 0520T Maytrees 2011.06 New server populated with 6 drives and original firmware. Worked with no errors for 4 days.  Did auto update of firmware and no errors for a day. NAS on 24/7
HDS5C3020ALA632
 ML06
 2000 (1863)
 5
 TS-409
 3.3.0 build 0924T
 ElSalvador
 2011.06
 Failed "Expand RAID" process after 4 days. Tech Support said "not on compat list" (ie "you're on your own") No drives over 1Tbyte on the list, so nice get-out. Seems to work generally though.

H3IK30003272SW


3000 1 TS-219P+ 3.4.2 Build 0520 epicfailrobot 2011.07 Running two of these 7200RPM SATA 6.0Gb/s 3.5" drives in a RAID 1 - no issues. Formatted at 2,749GB.
HDS5C3020ALA632
 ML60
 2000
 5
 TS439 Pro
 3.4.2 Build 0331T
 atari_Mark
 2011.08
 Replace 4*1TB disks (one by one) then expanded RAID5. No problems, been running a week.
HDS723020BLA642
 MN6OA5C0
 2000
 1
 TS-259 Pro+
3.3.9 Build 0104T
 Garvs
 2011.08

2 of these in RAID1. So far so good.

Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives


Seagate

Model Number HD FW Capacity (GB) RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark
ST4000NM0033 SN04 4000 6 TS-870 ultra since 4.0 baten 2015.01 have been using 6 of these since I purchased ts-870, in January 2014, in raid 6. I have just added 2x dell version with firmware GA06. expanded storage pool. still running superfine
ST4000DM000 CC52 4000 5 TS-469L 3.8.3 Build 20130426  Jonny0r 2013.04

Works fine since around 2 month, no problems with creating the raid, good speed, nothing to complain!

ST33000650NS 0004 3000 5 TS-469  3.7.3 Build 20120801  w m0zart 2012.10

 

ST31500541AS CC34 1500 5 TS-410  3.1.2 build 1207T  Villy 2010.01

 

ST3500418AS CC35 500 Single TS-209 Pro II 3.1.0 build 0708T Gnulab  

 

ST32000542AS CC34 2000 5 TS-419P 3.2.5 Build 0409T shades 2010.05

 

ST32000542AS CC35 2000 5 TS-409 3.3.1 Build 0823T PoPPaP 2011.11  
ST16000NM001G-2KK103
 SN02 16000 Single and 5 TS-469L 4.3.4.1463 Build 20201006 mcfudge 2021.01 works as single drive and RAID5
ST2000DL003 CC32 2000 5 TS-410 3.4.0 Build 0212T AirtjE 2011.03 These are SATA III (6Gb/s) 4K disks

Config: 3x for RAID5

ST2000DL004

HD204UI

1AQ1 2000 1 TS-412 3.7.1 NASoverdose 2012.07  
ST2000VX002 CV01 2000 5 TS-419P II 3.6.1 Build 0302T Shade99GT 2012.02 SATA 3 (6Gb/s) 5900rpm 64MB cache drives - No problems in a 4 disk RAID 5 setup
ST2000DL003 CC32 2000 10 TS-419P 3.6.1 Build 0302T Kim Haverblad 2012.06 Two Disks running with RAID 10 together with two WDC drives. Been running for well over a year without any issues.
ST3000DM001 CC4H 3000 6 TS-869 Pro 3.7.1 Build 0614T adprom 2012.06 8 Disks running in RAID6 well and fairly quiet. Note: These drives must be upgraded to firmware CC4H which resolves known issues
ST3000DM001 CC4H 3000 Single NMP-1000 1.2.0 Build 1125P www.itilit.be 2012.09 No single issue. Installed since a few months
ST31500541AS   1500 Single TS-209 3.3.2 Build 0918T James 2012.09  
ST2000VX000 CV13 2000 Single TS-209 3.3.2 Build 0918T James 2012.09  
ST1000DM003 CC4C 1000 Single TS-112 3.7.3 Build 20120801 irving 2012.09 first initialization and firmware update took a couple of hours; needed to use Chrome browser just to be able to recognize any progress in firmware upload process(neither in FF nor in IE could do that)
ST1000NM0011 SN03 1000 1 TS-209 Pro II 3.3.0 Build 0924T Erik Knowles 2012.12 Didn't seem to recognize via hot swap to correct broken raid drive. Shutting down and restarting worked fine. RAID rebuilt using 1 old drive and 1 new, then I shut the system down again and swapped out the other old drive. On restart raid rebuilt again and all OK.
ST1000DM003 CC4B 1000 4 TS-439 Pro 3.8.0 Build 20121114 ekhoo 2013.01

Replaced an incompatible WD drive. Runs fine. Other 3 drives in the 4-disk array are Seagate ST31000528AS with firmware CC35

ST2000DM001 CC24 2000 10 TS-459 Pro II 3.8.2 Build 0301  An3k 2013.09

Have four of these running for over 6 month. Zero problems. Also on 4.0.2 Build 0726

ST1000NC001 1DY1CN02 1000 1 TS-219P 4.0.7 axel3rd 2014.04

RAID 1 with SAMSUNG HD103UJ 1AA0

ST12000VN0008 2YSC60/2PSC61 12000 single and 1 TS-439Pro 4.2.6 Build 2021/12/15 tnt 2022.02

RAID 5 dosnt work because of 16TB limitation

Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives


Western Digital

Critical: WD Caviar Black, Caviar Green, and Caviar Blue hard drives are not recommended for and are not warranted for use in RAID environments utilizing Enterprise HBAs and/or expanders and in multi-bay chassis, as they are not designed for, nor tested in, these specific types of RAID applications. For more info, please refer to the following link. (http://wdc.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/1397)

Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives

Model Number HD FW Capacity
( TB ) 		RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remarks
WD Caviar SE WD3200AAJS
320 GB




Spindown: Yes, Copy of original User Reported Compatible Hard Drives page
WDC WD5003ABYX-01WER01.0 04.05G05 500 GB 4 TS-439proII+ 3.3.2 Build 0819T RoSa 2010.12

4 drives Setup in RAID 5. Drives have 64MB Cache and
labled Enterprise Storage. Works perfectly with ESXi3.5
and iSCSI Targets.

No read/write errors or performance issues.
Disks are not encrypted (makes hardly sense for a raid array)

WDC WD5000AAKS-07YGA0 12.01C02 500 GB 1 TS-459 Pro+ 3.5.1 build 1002T mikahe 2011.10 SATA II RAID 1 with Samsung HD501LJ
WD Caviar Green WD6400AADS-00M2B01.0 01.00A01 640 GB Single TS-119 3.3.6 Build 1109 hardstyler 2010.11 No issues, very quiet.
WD10EAVS-00D7B1 01.0 1 TB
TS-209p 3.3.0 Merry 11-2010 Works intern. Attaching it by USB does not work!
WDC WD10EARS-00Y5B1 80.0 1 TB 1 TS-210 3.4.2 Build 0331T Ali Saleh 2011.05 Had These Drives In Raid 1 with NAS Running Over 1 Year Now - No Problem - Quiet - Fast - Perfect
WDC WD10EACS-22D6B0 01.01A01 1 TB 1 TS-253 Pro 4.2.0 RaceDuck 2015.11
WDC WD1002FBYS-02A6B0 03.00C06 1 TB 5 TS-509 Pro 3.1.1
3.1.2
3.2.0 1212T 		Yeroon 2009.09 These RE3 drives are very reliable harddives, designed for RAID config. did not had any issues with 3 of them using them in raid 5 config.
WD Caviar Green WD10EADS
1 TB




Spindown: Yes, Copy of original User Reported Compatible Hard Drives page
WDC WD10EZEX 08RKKA080.0 1 TB Single TS-112 3.8.1 csumy 2012.12 No problem, works great with high speed.
WDC WD10EZRX   1 TB 5 TS-420 4.0.5 Stefan 2013.12 No problem, RAID5 with 4 equal disks.
WDC WD15EADS-00P8B0 01.00A01 1.5TB 0 TS-439 Pro 3.1.1 0815T,
3.1.2 1014,
3.2.0 1107 Beta 		Kanchelsis 2009.11

Several users report reliability and performance issues during I/O operations like (1) high LCC counts and (2) freezes and hiccups. WDIDLE3 may solve (1).  (2) remains unsolved.

edit: these desktop drives are not supported for RAID use by Western Digital

WDC WD2002FYPS-01U1B0 04.05G05 2 TB 1 TS-509 pro 3.2.0 1212T Yeroon 2009.11

Flash these RE4-GP drives with at least firmware 04.05G05 for operation in RAID configuration. You can easily fix high LCC counts by use of the WDIDLE3 tool. No real issues encountered with these drives.

download bootable CD with right FW and WDIDLE tool here: http://wdcutil.homeip.net

WDC WD2002FYPS-01U1B1 04.05G05 2 TB 6 TS-809RP 3.2.3 0209T ftan 2010.3 8 drives came directly from WD with the latest firmware. Setup in RAID 6. So far 1270 Hours ~ 9500 LCC. Did not WDIDLE.

Raid and drive stable since build, no read/write errors or performance issues.

WDC WD20EARS-00S8B1 80.0 80.00A80 2 TB (decimal)
1863GB (binary) 		JBOD TS-210 3.2.3 0209T doofas 2010.06 Single "Green" SATA ATA-8 drive; very quiet.
No issues seen during installation and approximately 2 months of NAS uptime
WDC WD20EARX-00PASB0531.0 51.0AB51 2 TB Single TS-412 3.8.2 Wond1979 2013.03 No problem, works great in single mode quiet and slow temp.
WD Caviar Green WD20EADS-00R6B0
2 TB




Copy of original Compatible Hard Drives(3.5") page
WD Caviar Green WD20EARS-00J2GB080.0
2 TB RAID5 TS-439 Pro II 3.3.1 Build 0720T brad_peraso 2010.06 No issues; very quiet.
WDC WD20EARS 07MVWB051.0 2 TB 10 TS-419P 3.6.1 Build 0302T Kim Haverblad 2012.06 Two Disks running with RAID 10 together with two Seagate drives. Been running for well over a year without any issues.
WD Caviar 3 TB
(WD30EZRX)
3 TB
TS-119 3.4.4
Build0718 		maierhe 2011.07 NAS works well with WD WD30EZRS and very quiet. HDD temperature with constant access to approximately 40°C/104°F. According to WD permitted to 60 ° C/140F.
WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX
3 TB 0 TS-239 Pro II+ 3.5.0 Build 0815 carfesh 2011.09 Two disks prepared with wdidle3 /d, configured into a RAID-0. Performing fine.
WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX 00MMMB080.0 3 TB 0
Stripped 		T-210 3.5.1 B1002 Jonny0r 2011.11 Two Disks, but there was problems with the Firmware because i got the T-210 with 3.1.8 and this FW does not support 3TB, so i did it with a 1TB HDD and upgrade to 3.5.1 and exchange to 2x 3TB works fine ..!!
WD Caviar Green WD30EZRX 80.00A80 3 TB 5 TS-439 Pro 3.5.2 build 1126T Davide.f75 2012.01 it is recommended to disable applications in the NAS during RAID volume expansion, and this for any hard drive, regardless of compatibility with the NAS !!
WD Caviar Green
WD30EZRX 		80.00A80 3 TB 5 TS-559 Pro+ 3.7.3 build 20120801 buggy82 2013.01 Very quiet, very fast and not a single problem yet. 3+ months running in a RAID-5 Array of five disks.
WDC WD30EFRX 80.00A8 3 TB 4 TS-469L 3.8.1 Rafale 2012.12 4x Caviar RED in RAID5. works great.
WDC WD80EFBX 85.00A85 8 TB 6 TS-469L 4.3.4 Spyder 2022.05 4x WD Red Plus 8TB, 16~24 hours per drive rebuild, ~12 hours pool expansion, no issues.
The 2-6 TB models are verified, so suspected newer 8 TB also will work, comments on expansion max to 16TB made me choose 8TB vs larger in case could not expand, vs full rebuild.


Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives

Samsung

Model Number HD FW Capacity (GB) RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark
HD753LJ (Spinpoint F1) 7200 750GB 1 TS-209 3.1.0 rogo 2009.11 Spindown did not work on very old firmware
HD103SJ (Spinpoint F3) 1AJ10001 1TB 1 TS-219P 3.3.1 NiNiX 2010-08
HD154UI 1AG0 1.5TB 1 TS-209P 3.3.0 Merry 2010-11
HD204UI 1AQ1 2TB 1 TS-209P 3.3.0 Merry 2011-01
SpinPoint T166 series HD501LJ
 CR100-13
 500
 1
 TS-459 Pro+
 3.5.1
 mikahe
 2011-10
 RAID 1 with WDC WD5000AAKS
HD103UJ
 1AA0
 1TB
 1
 TS-219P
 4.0.7
 axel3rd
 2014-04
 RAID 1 with Seagate Constellation CS ST1000NC001 since 04/2014


Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives


Incompatible Hard Drives(3.5")

Hitachi

Model Number HD FW Capacity (GB) RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark










Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives


Seagate

Model Number HD FW Capacity (GB) RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark
ST31000340AS 7200.11 1TB Single TS-219P 3.1.0 ff 2009.11 don't support standby mode
ST2000DL003
 CC32
 2000
 1
 TS-412
 3.7.1
 NASoverdose
 2012.07

not recommended, random read/write errors, discs fine (DOM 06/2011)



Western Digital

Model Number HD FW Capacity (GB) RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark
HGST / Hitachi Ultrastar He10 0F27607 / HUH721010ALN600 10TB 3.5" 6Gbps   10TB * TR-004   Martijn071 2020.08.07 Smart error and red LEDs. SoftwareWSoftware not working. When individual disks no smart errors are visible
WD10EARS   1TB 1 TS-210 3.3.9 MADhase 2011.02

State LED (red) is flashing all the time.
Web Interface not coming up:
Probably the NAS is stuck at boot time during
mounting the drive(s).

WD20EARX 00PASB051.0 2TB 6 TS-459+ & TS-879U 3.7.3 Build 20120801   2012.08

Extremely bad performance.

Connected to ESXi 5.0 host via iSCSI: Virtual machines on the host had a max read speed of 20 Mbyte/sec

vCenter logged 'I/O performance  deterioration' events every 15secs.

RAID6 appears to be OK and working.

Resource monitor on QNAP showed max. throughput of 30Mbyte/sec on 1Gbit ethernet interfaces under full read/write load. (it should be close to 100Mbyte/sec)

 

WDC WD10EZEX 

08RKKA080.0
  		1 TB
  		1 of 4 Disks in RAID5
  		TS-439 Pro
  		3.8.0 Build 20121114
  		ekhoo
  		2013.01
  		Replaced disk 3 (Disk 1-2-4 are Seagate 7200.12 - ST31000528AS) and my whole array slowed drastically until close to being unusable. Transfer speeds burst up to 3-4mb/s then dropped to around 80-200kb/s. Replaced with Seagate 1TB ST1000DM003 and everything's back to normal.


Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives

 

Samsung

Model Number HD FW Capacity (GB) RAID NAS Model Firmware Reporter YYYY.MM Remark










Source(s):   Compatible Hard Drives

Retrieved from "https://wiki.qnap.com/mediawiki/index.php?title=Compatible/Incompatible_Hard_Drives(3.5&oldid=1706"